California Employment Law

Other Forms of Sexual Harassment at Work: California Law

Benjamin Eghbali, Esq.Reviewed by Benjamin Eghbali, Esq.,

Staring, rumors, 'jokes,' digital conduct - sexual harassment has forms most workers don't recognize as illegal. California law can reach each of them when the conduct is severe or pervasive and based on sex.

Employees only No fee unless we win 24/7 intake
Sexual Harassment, Eghbali Law Firm Sexual Harassment

Sexual harassment does not require physical contact or explicit words. California law recognizes that non-verbal conduct, visual materials, digital behavior, and a wide range of other actions can create an illegal hostile work environment. If something at your workplace makes you feel sexually targeted, objectified, or unsafe, even if no one touched you and nothing was said directly, you may have a harassment claim.

The short answer

  • You can experience sexual harassment without being touched or hearing sexual words. California protects you against harassment because of sex, including gender harassment; the person does not have to be attracted to you.1, 2
  • Your earlier interactions can explain a later look, gesture or unwanted visit. A California appeals court allowed a claim to proceed when repeated staring followed rejected advances, and a federal appeals court, applying federal and Washington law, did the same when romantic attention continued after rejection.3, 4
  • You may have a separate image claim as the person depicted or as the recipient. California uses different rules for publicly disclosed, digitally created or altered sexual material and for unsolicited obscene images sent electronically.5, 6
  • You have specific privacy protections in workplace restrooms and changing rooms. Peeping, concealed recording and an employer's own recording are covered by different provisions with different requirements.7, 8
  • You do not have to fit someone else's expectations about gender to receive protection. California's protections also reach harassment connected to gender identity, gender expression, pregnancy, childbirth and breastfeeding.1, 9

How California FEHA Defines Sexual Harassment Broadly

California's Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), Government Code section 12940(j), makes harassment because of sex unlawful, and section 12940(j)(4)(C) says that includes sexual harassment, gender harassment, and harassment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions, even without sexual desire. A FEHA regulation says harassment includes, but is not limited to, verbal, physical and visual harassment, and unwanted sexual advances that condition an employment benefit on sexual favors. FEHA's reach is intentionally broad: the Legislature says its provisions "shall be construed liberally," and that harassment creates a hostile work environment when it sufficiently offends, humiliates, distresses, or intrudes upon you so as to disrupt your emotional tranquility at work.

For the rest of California sexual harassment law, see our California sexual harassment lawyer page.

The law distinguishes between two categories of harassment:

  • Quid pro quo: Conditioning employment on sexual compliance (covered in depth on our Requesting Sexual Favors page)
  • Hostile work environment: Conduct that is severe or pervasive enough to alter the conditions of employment and create an abusive working environment

The forms of harassment covered on this page primarily fall under the hostile work environment category, and they can support a claim even when there is no physical touching or explicit verbal request.

What the statute actually protects you against

You can be protected even when the mistreatment has no romantic or erotic purpose. Government Code section 12940(j)(4)(C) says harassment because of sex includes sexual harassment, gender harassment, and harassment based on pregnancy, childbirth or related medical conditions; it expressly says sexual desire is unnecessary. That wording matters when someone uses your sex as a reason to intimidate or humiliate you rather than to seek a relationship.1

A list of forms appears in California Code of Regulations, title 2, section 11019(b)(2). It says harassment includes, but is not limited to, verbal, physical and visual harassment, and unwanted sexual advances that condition an employment benefit on sexual favors. Its physical category expressly includes interfering with or blocking movement on a protected basis, so physical interference does not depend on skin touching skin. Its visual category includes derogatory posters, cartoons and drawings on a protected basis.2

The Civil Rights Department's Sexual Harassment Fact Sheet lists leering, gestures, displays of sexually suggestive objects, pictures, cartoons or posters, and impeding or blocking movements among the behaviors that may be sexual harassment. You do not need to turn an incident into a spoken proposition before you describe what happened to you.10

For how these forms fit the legal categories, see our types of sexual harassment guide.

Who can be responsible for the conduct

An employee can be personally responsible for their own unlawful harassment. Government Code section 12940(j)(3) imposes that responsibility regardless of whether the employer knew or should have known and failed to respond. Section 12940(j)(1) separately addresses the employer's responsibility, including whether it knew or should have known of nonsupervisory coworker harassment and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action; the two questions should be assessed separately in your situation. The same subdivision protects applicants, unpaid interns, volunteers and people providing services under a contract, and it can make your employer responsible for harassment by nonemployees, such as customers, when the employer, its agents or supervisors know or should have known of the conduct and fail to take immediate and appropriate corrective action.1

Which additional law matches an image or privacy incident

More than one legal provision may apply to what happened to you. The table connects workplace protections to the separate image, privacy and exposure laws explained below; each additional law has its own requirements.2, 1, 5, 6, 7, 8, 11, 12

Form of conductFEHA or regulationOther provision that may apply
Digitally created or altered sexual depictionsVisual conduct can be assessed under title 2, section 11019(b)(2)(C).2Civil Code section 1708.86 (civil claim); Penal Code section 647(j)(4)(A)(ii) (crime).5, 7
Unsolicited obscene electronic imagesVisual conduct can be assessed under title 2, section 11019(b)(2)(C).2Civil Code section 1708.88 (civil claim).6
Privacy-invading viewing or concealed recordingSex-based conduct can also be assessed under section 12940(j).1Penal Code section 647(j)(1) to (3) (crimes).7
Employer recording in specified private roomsSex-based conduct can also be assessed under section 12940(j).1Labor Code section 435 (an infraction).8
Deliberate lewd exposureSex-based conduct can also be assessed under section 12940(j).1Penal Code section 314 (crime); its elements are set out in jury instruction No. 1160 of the Judicial Council of California Criminal Jury Instructions (CALCRIM).11, 12

Why an older losing case may not answer your situation

An old decision rejecting another worker's claim does not automatically defeat yours. Several cases discussed below were decided before Government Code section 12923 took effect on January 1, 2019. That section says a single incident can be enough to create a triable issue if it unreasonably interfered with your work performance or created an intimidating, hostile, or offensive working environment, and that you do not have to prove your tangible productivity declined. Courts now read it to mean a single incident does not have to be a physical assault or threat. You still have to establish your claim under the current law and the circumstances of your experience.13, 14

In Wawrzenski v. United Airlines, Inc. (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th 663, a flight attendant challenged repeated comments about the attendant's body and uniform. The Court of Appeal held that the harassment claim could not be decided without a trial and explained that older language requiring a physical assault or its threat for an isolated incident is no longer the law. Quoting an earlier appellate decision, the court also said that cases decided before section 12923 are no longer good law on what conduct creates a hostile work environment when a court is asked to decide the claim without a trial. That is why older decisions should be read for their actual facts and any reasoning that remains consistent with today's statute.14

Section 12923 also says the legal standard should not vary by type of workplace, and that it is irrelevant that an occupation has had more sexual commentary or conduct in the past; a court may consider the nature of the workplace only when engaging in or witnessing prurient conduct and commentary is integral to the job duties. It expressly disapproves contrary reasoning in Kelley v. Conco Companies (2011) 196 Cal.App.4th 191, rather than erasing every pre-2019 opinion. Our hostile work environment guide explains the complete standard.13

Non-Verbal Sexual Harassment

Non-verbal sexual harassment is conduct aimed at you because of sex, such as staring, gestures or blocking your way, that happens without words being spoken. This is one of the most commonly misunderstood categories, many victims are told "nothing happened" because there was no speech or physical contact. That is legally incorrect.

Non-verbal conduct that can constitute sexual harassment includes:

  • Leering and staring: Persistent, deliberate sexual staring at an employee's body, especially when the victim has indicated discomfort, can be non-verbal harassment. It communicates sexual objectification without a word being spoken.
  • Sexual gestures: Obscene gestures, mimicking sexual acts, or making suggestive hand signals directed at or in the presence of an employee.
  • Blocking movement: Physically positioning oneself to block an employee's path, corner them, or prevent them from leaving a space, creating physical intimidation of a sexual nature.
  • Inappropriate body language: Deliberate, suggestive positioning, repeatedly standing too close in a sexualized way, or mimicking sexual attention directed at an employee.
  • Winking or blowing kisses: Persistent sexual non-verbal communications directed at an employee who has not welcomed them.
  • Unwanted sexually suggestive gifts or notes: Anonymous or attributed written materials, gifts, or objects with sexual connotations left at an employee's workspace.

When repeated watching carries an earlier message

You can still be harassed when someone replaces rejected advances with prolonged staring. The meaning of the watching depends on its context, including earlier interactions, its frequency and duration, and what changed after you objected.3

In Birschtein v. New United Motor Manufacturing, Inc. (2001) 92 Cal.App.4th 994, an assembly-line worker described rejected invitations and explicit comments followed by repeated watching from a forklift. The worker's account included five to ten visits a day, with some staring lasting five to ten minutes, and later two or three shorter episodes a day after another complaint. The Court of Appeal reversed a summary judgment for the employer because a jury could find the silent staring was a continuation of the earlier sex-based harassment.3

For you, the useful point is the connection between events: a person who stops saying the words may continue communicating the same unwanted message through conduct. The decision does not establish a minimum number of looks or minutes, and it did not involve staring stripped of all prior sexual context.3

When movement and proximity interfere with your work

You do not have to be touched for physical positioning to matter. Section 11019(b)(2)(B) lists impeding or blocking movement, or any physical interference with normal work or movement, when directed at you on a protected basis, and the Civil Rights Department lists impeding or blocking movements among behaviors that may be sexual harassment.2, 10

Applied to your experience, the distinction is between describing the action and explaining its meaning. Where someone stood, whether you could pass or leave, whether they repeatedly repositioned when you moved, and how the conduct related to earlier treatment can explain why an encounter was intimidating. Those are ways to apply the regulation's physical-interference example and the contextual reasoning in the staring case, rather than a rule that every close encounter in a crowded workplace is harassment.2, 3

The same distinction helps when someone repeatedly follows you between work areas: the pattern and its connection to sex matter, not simply the fact that two employees used the same corridor.1 For harassment through email, chat, text or social media, use our remote work and digital harassment guide.

When romantic attention continues after you say no

You do not have to accept persistent attention because the person describes it as romance. In Christian v. Umpqua Bank (9th Cir. 2020) 984 F.3d 801, a bank worker described a customer's repeated date requests, notes and flowers after rejection, followed by prolonged watching that included 45 minutes to an hour in the lobby. The Ninth Circuit reversed summary judgment for the bank on harassment claims under federal and Washington law: the incidents had to be considered together, including letters, flowers and watching with no direct contact, and a jury could find that the bank ratified or acquiesced in the customer's harassment.4

This is a federal case that states federal and Washington law, not the California rule. What it illustrates is that repeated appearances can take their meaning from an ignored refusal and a continuing pursuit, and that a card or delivery does not have to contain graphic words to be part of that pattern. The decision allowed the claim to proceed; it did not make every invitation or gift unlawful.4

If the person is a customer, client or vendor, our third-party harassment guide explains the employer's responsibility.

Why accepting a gift does not settle whether attention was welcome

Accepting something from a supervisor does not by itself mean you welcomed the entire course of attention. In Lewis v. City of Benicia (2014) 224 Cal.App.4th 1519, a city intern described months of gifts and lunches from a male supervisor, alongside explicit images, sexual comments and invitations. The Court of Appeal held that a jury could find harassment even though the intern had not refused the gifts, noting the intern's testimony that the gifts were unwelcome and never used, and it revived the harassment claims against that supervisor and the city.15

The surrounding relationship matters to what your response means. Receiving an item, remaining polite at work or not rejecting every interaction individually may be part of the evidence, but none should be lifted out of the whole account as conclusive proof that the attention was welcome. This case involved substantially more than gifts, so it supplies a lesson about context rather than a gifts-alone rule.15

Visual Sexual Harassment

Visual harassment involves exposing employees to sexually explicit, suggestive, or demeaning imagery in the workplace. A FEHA regulation expressly lists visual forms of harassment, such as derogatory posters, cartoons, or drawings, and the California Civil Rights Department (CRD) lists sexually suggestive pictures, cartoons and posters among behaviors that may be sexual harassment.

Visual sexual harassment can include:

  • Displaying sexually explicit photographs, posters, calendars, or drawings in shared workspaces
  • Using sexually explicit images as computer screensavers, wallpapers, or backgrounds in shared or visible areas
  • Circulating sexual images via email, text, Slack, or other platforms to employees who did not request them
  • Leaving sexual materials, magazines, printouts, objects, at an employee's workstation
  • Displaying sexual cartoons, memes, or illustrations in shared digital workspaces
  • Showing an employee explicit videos or images on a phone or screen without consent

It does not matter whether the material was created by the harasser or simply shared. Deliberately exposing employees to sexually explicit content in a work context can be harassment, especially when it is aimed at you or at people of your sex. Calling an image "just a joke," or sending it in an email chain, does not by itself make it lawful. The law asks whether a reasonable person in your position would find the environment hostile or abusive, and whether you did.

When an image of you becomes a tool of humiliation

A sexualized picture of you can help establish harassment when it is used to humiliate you at work. In Taylor v. Nabors Drilling USA, LP (2014) 222 Cal.App.4th 1228, an oil-rig worker's two supervisors repeatedly subjected the worker to homophobic slurs and other degrading sexual conduct, and one of them posted the worker's photograph in the employees' restroom with a target around the mouth and a sexual caption. The Court of Appeal upheld the harassment verdict, explaining that sex was used as a weapon whether or not the harassers had any sexual interest; the picture was part of the evidence that supported the verdict.16

This connects a display to the way you are treated. Who is depicted, what has been added to the image, where it appears, who encounters it, and the surrounding conduct can explain its workplace message. In that case, the crew laughed at the photograph, and the harassment verdict still stood.16

What an older case about one drawing actually decided

A decision about one historical display is not permission to circulate sexual material about you. In Herberg v. California Institute of the Arts (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th 142, students displayed a sexually explicit drawing depicting an employee at an art-school exhibition for about a day, and the employee saw it only after its removal. The court upheld judgment for the employer under its then-applied approach to the seriousness of an isolated incident and left the separate question whether the conduct occurred because of sex unresolved.17

That 2002 decision predates section 12923. Read it with the current rule described above: a single incident can be enough to create a triable issue if it unreasonably interfered with your work performance or created an intimidating, hostile, or offensive working environment, and it does not have to be a physical assault or threat. A display that lasted one day is therefore not harmless by definition; whether your circumstances establish a claim depends on the current standard.13, 14

Why sexual content alone does not answer every question

You need the workplace meaning of a display assessed, including its connection to sex-based treatment. In Lyle v. Warner Brothers Television Productions (2006) 38 Cal.4th 264, a comedy writers' assistant challenged graphic brainstorming, gestures and drawings in a television writers' room. The California Supreme Court held that no reasonable jury could find sexual harassment on that record: most of the sexual talk and antics were not aimed at the assistant or at women, the remarks about other women were not severe or pervasive enough, and the creative work on an adult comedy was significant context.18

The useful distinction is between proving that sexual material existed and proving what environment you experienced because of sex. This pre-2019 decision supplies no general exemption for entertainment or any other industry; the court said similar language "might well establish actionable harassment depending on the circumstances." Today, section 12923(d) lets a court consider the nature of a workplace only when engaging in or witnessing prurient conduct and commentary is integral to the job duties, and in that case listening to and transcribing the writers' sexual jokes was part of the assistant's job.18, 13

For when exposure to conduct directed at someone else supports a claim of your own, see our witness and bystander harassment guide.

Watching, recording and exposure in private work areas

When watching becomes an invasion of a private space

You have specific protection against deliberate viewing into places where you reasonably expect privacy. Penal Code section 647(j)(1) addresses looking through an opening or using a camera or other instrument to view inside specified rooms, including bathrooms and changing rooms, with intent to invade an occupant's privacy. It does not require nudity or a sexual motive, although it has an express exception for private-business areas used to count currency or other negotiable instruments.7

Two additional provisions address secret recording. Section 647(j)(2) covers using a concealed camera to record an identifiable person under or through clothing to view the body or underwear, without knowledge or consent, where privacy is reasonably expected; it requires both an intent to invade privacy and the specified purpose of sexual arousal or gratification. Section 647(j)(3) instead addresses concealed recording for viewing an identifiable person's body or underwear in a bedroom, bathroom, changing room, fitting room, dressing room or tanning booth, or any other area where the person has a reasonable expectation of privacy, without knowledge or consent and with intent to invade privacy.7

Under the private-room provision, the fact that you were not actually undressed is not a defense. Nor is it a defense that the person was your employer, employee, business partner or associate, landlord, tenant, cotenant or cohabitant, or an agent of one of them. For both recording provisions, someone must be able to recognize the recorded person, but that someone can be you; these distinctions keep the inquiry focused on what the person deliberately viewed or recorded and the privacy of the setting.7

When the camera belongs to your employer

Your employer ordinarily cannot record you in a restroom, locker room or designated changing room. Labor Code section 435 prohibits an employer from causing an audio or video recording of an employee in those rooms unless a court order authorizes it, and it forbids employer use of an unlawful recording for any purpose. The section applies to public and private employers except the federal government and makes a violation an infraction.8

This protection does not depend on proving that the employer wanted sexual images or used a hidden camera. A posted notice or an employee's supposed consent is not the court-order exception the statute provides. The rule covers recording an employee in those rooms. It is not a ban on every camera at work.8

When someone exposes themselves without touching you

Deliberate sexual exposure can be a criminal offense even when nobody touches you. Penal Code section 314 makes it a crime to willfully and lewdly expose one's person or private parts in a public place, or in a place where other people are present who could be offended or annoyed. The Judicial Council's jury instruction for this crime, CALCRIM No. 1160, lists what the prosecution must prove: willful exposure of the genitals in the presence of someone who might be offended or annoyed, with intent to direct public attention to the genitals for sexual arousal or gratification, or to sexually offend another person.11, 12

The required intent separates the offense from accidental nudity. The jury instruction says another person does not have to actually see the exposed genitals, and the statute reaches any place where other people are present who could be offended or annoyed, so a privately owned workplace is not excluded simply because it is not a public street. Those are criminal-law rules; the same conduct, when it is based on sex, can also be assessed under FEHA's workplace protections.12, 11, 1

For incidents involving touching or assault, see our sexual assault at work guide.

Digital and Online Sexual Harassment

As work has moved increasingly online, through remote work, digital communication platforms, and social media, sexual harassment has followed. California law applies fully to digital conduct, and digital harassment often leaves a written record, although platforms can be set to delete messages after a set time.

Workplace Platform Harassment (Slack, Teams, Email)

Sending unwanted sexual messages, images, or content through workplace communication tools can be sexual harassment under FEHA. This includes:

  • Sexually suggestive messages in direct messages or group chats
  • Sexual emojis, GIFs, or memes sent repeatedly to an unwilling recipient
  • Sharing or forwarding explicit content through workplace channels
  • Making sexual comments about an employee in group chats visible to colleagues

Personal Device and Social Media Harassment

Harassment that begins on personal devices or social media can still give rise to a workplace harassment claim if it affects the work environment. Examples include:

  • A supervisor who sends unwanted sexual messages to an employee via personal text or Instagram
  • A coworker who makes sexual posts about an employee on their personal social media that colleagues see
  • An employer who monitors an employee's personal social media and makes sexualized comments about what they find

The key is whether the digital conduct spills into the work environment, whether it affects the victim's ability to do their job comfortably, changes how colleagues treat them, or creates an environment they dread entering.

Unsolicited Explicit Content (Cyberflashing)

Sending unsolicited explicit images, sometimes called "cyberflashing", via AirDrop, text, email, or any digital means to an employee who did not request them can be a form of sexual harassment. California also gives the recipient a separate civil claim against an adult who knowingly sends an unsolicited obscene image by electronic means, under Civil Code section 1708.88.

A separate civil claim when you receive an obscene image

Apart from any workplace harassment claim, you may have a civil claim of your own against the sender, even when you are not the person pictured. Civil Code section 1708.88 requires a sender aged 18 or older who knowingly sends an electronic image and knows or reasonably should know it is unsolicited; the material must be legally obscene. The section includes moving images, sets no recipient age threshold, and defines unsolicited as receipt without your consent or after your express prohibition. Its current provision took effect January 1, 2023.6

Obscenity has three required parts: considered as a whole, the material appeals to the average person's prurient interest under contemporary statewide standards; it depicts or describes sexual conduct in a patently offensive way; and it lacks serious literary, artistic, political or scientific value. The definition expressly includes images showing a person engaging in sexual intercourse, sodomy, oral copulation, sexual penetration or masturbation, or showing anyone's exposed genitals or anus, but those images also must meet all three parts.6

A prevailing recipient must have suffered harm from receiving it, and may recover economic and noneconomic damages. If you had expressly forbidden receipt beforehand, you may choose statutory damages of not less than $1,500 and not more than $30,000 in place of those damages, and may also seek punitive damages; you do not need an advance refusal to bring the claim itself. Exclusions cover providers and applications merely transmitting others' communications, services transmitting images or audiovisual works, a health-care provider transmitting an image for a legitimate medical purpose, and a recipient who did not expressly opt out where the service offered that option. This creates a private civil action rather than an automatic criminal charge for every unsolicited picture.6

When a realistic sexual image falsely depicts you

You may have a civil claim when realistic sexual material falsely depicts you. Civil Code section 1708.86, in its current version effective January 1, 2026, covers visual or audiovisual material created or substantially altered to realistically portray another person's or computer-generated nude body parts as yours, or you participating in sexual conduct that you did not perform. Its definition of disclosure means publishing, making available or distributing the material to the public.5, 31

The section defines the covered nudity and sexual acts. Nudity includes visible genitals, pubic area, anus or a female's postpubescent nipple or areola; sexual conduct includes masturbation, intercourse, vaginal or rectal penetration with an object, direct ejaculation onto the depicted individual through sexual conduct, and sadomasochistic abuse involving that individual. A humiliating alteration does not fall within this particular statute merely because it is insulting; it must fit the defined material.5

As the depicted person, you can sue a person who creates and intentionally discloses the material when that person knows, or reasonably should know, that you did not consent to its creation or disclosure, or that you were a minor when it was created. A person who did not create it faces a different branch: intentionally disclosing it when that person knows, or reasonably should know, that you did not consent to its creation, or that you were a minor when it was created. Knowing facilitators and those who recklessly aid or abet either violation can also be liable.5

What consent means for digitized sexually explicit material

Agreeing to an ordinary photograph does not supply the special consent this statute requires. Section 1708.86 defines consent as a knowingly and voluntarily signed, plain-language agreement generally describing the digitally created or altered sexual material and the work incorporating it. You may withdraw consent by delivering written notice to the person in whose favor you gave it within three business days after giving it, unless you had at least 72 hours to review before signing or your authorized attorney, talent agent or personal manager approved the signed agreement in writing.5

A disclaimer that you did not participate in or authorize the depiction does not defeat liability. The statute nevertheless preserves exceptions for reporting unlawful activity, law-enforcement duties, legal proceedings, legitimate public concern, political or newsworthy works, similar works, and constitutionally protected commentary, criticism or disclosure; being a public figure alone does not make the material newsworthy. For private recovery, a prevailing depicted person must have suffered harm. Public prosecutors, such as the Attorney General, a district attorney or a city attorney, can separately bring a civil action to enforce the section without proving that the depicted person suffered actual harm.5

When the service that produced the material may be responsible

The people behind a service devoted to producing this material may also face responsibility. Under section 1708.86, owning, operating or controlling a service whose primary purpose is creating the defined material counts as creation and intentional disclosure, with presumed knowledge of nonconsent unless express written consent is produced. A policy telling users not to create nonconsensual material does not itself defeat liability.5

A provider whose services enable such a service to keep operating can be presumed to be knowingly facilitating or recklessly aiding or abetting a violation if, after you or a public prosecutor send it sufficient evidence that it enables the service, it fails within 30 days to take all necessary steps to stop. The statute sets out what that evidence must include and how it must be sent.5

This is not a general deadline for removing images. The section does not apply to conduct protected by federal law, including Section 230 of Title 47 of the United States Code, and an internet service provider is not liable for merely transmitting, routing or providing access to someone else's content. Knowing who created, disclosed or enabled the material helps show which part of the statute fits.5

When creating and distributing an altered image can lead to charges

Creating and distributing a sexual image made to look authentic can also be a crime. Penal Code section 647(j)(4)(A)(ii) reaches a person aged 18 or older who intentionally creates a photo realistic, digital, electronic, computer or computer-generated image, or another pictorial representation, of another identifiable person and distributes it or causes it to be distributed. It must be created in a manner that would cause a reasonable person to believe it is an authentic image of that person. The person distributing it must know or should know that distribution will cause serious emotional distress, and the depicted person must actually suffer that distress.7

To qualify, the image must depict the person's intimate body parts or show that person involved in one of the listed sexual acts. Here, an intimate body part means any portion of the genitals or anus and, for a female, any portion of the breasts below the top of the areola, uncovered or clearly visible through clothing. The listed acts are sexual intercourse, sodomy, oral copulation, sexual penetration and masturbation involving the depicted person. These are the criminal provision's content limits, which differ from the civil statute's definitions.7

For this criminal rule, distribution includes publicly exhibiting material or giving someone possession; causing distribution includes arranging, specifically requesting or intentionally causing another person to distribute it. The statute preserves specified exceptions for reporting illegal activity, compliance with a subpoena or court order in a legal proceeding, a lawful public proceeding, and a matter of public concern or interest; public-figure status alone is insufficient.7

This digitally created-image branch took effect January 1, 2025, and remains in the version of section 647 effective January 1, 2026. It is a criminal provision enforced through prosecution, distinct from your private claim under Civil Code section 1708.86, and the two sections do not use identical disclosure or harm requirements.19, 31, 7, 5

For harassment on Zoom, Teams, Slack, email, shared documents, text messages and personal social media, see our remote work and digital harassment guide.

Harassment That Doesn't Fit a Single Category

Some forms of workplace sexual harassment defy easy categorization. The law does not require a neat label; it asks whether the conduct happened because of sex and was severe or pervasive. Additional forms of harassment covered by California FEHA include:

Stalking and Surveillance

An employee who is followed, monitored, or stalked, whether physically at work or digitally, by a coworker or supervisor because of sex may have a harassment claim, even if the person is not motivated by sexual desire. This includes following someone to their car, tracking their social media, or showing up at personal locations outside work.

Third-Party Harassment

California FEHA protection extends to harassment by non-employees, clients, customers, vendors, or contractors, if the employer knew or should have known about the conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. If a client repeatedly sends sexual messages to your work email and your employer tells you to "just ignore it," your employer may be liable.

Same-Sex and Gender-Non-Conforming Harassment

FEHA prohibits harassment regardless of the genders of the harasser and the victim. Same-sex harassment, harassment of transgender employees, and harassment targeting employees for not conforming to gender stereotypes are all fully covered.

Harassment for Refusing to Participate in a Sexualized Culture

If an employee is targeted, excluded, or penalized for refusing to participate in workplace sexual banter, jokes, or conduct, for being the person who does not laugh at the jokes or objects to the culture, that exclusion itself can be actionable harassment or retaliation.

When hostility is about your sex rather than sexual interest

You can experience gender harassment through a campaign to make your work harder or push you out. Government Code section 12940(j)(4)(C) includes gender harassment, and the cases recognize that a sex-based campaign can combine humiliation with exclusion or interference with work.1, 20, 3

In Accardi v. Superior Court (1993) 17 Cal.App.4th 341, a police officer alleged sabotage, withheld assistance, unequal assignments, exclusion and rumors that the officer obtained assignments through sex with superior officers. The court directed that the officer's harassment claim be allowed to proceed, explaining that sex-based intimidation need not take the form of sexual advances. These were allegations accepted at that stage, and the court required consideration of the alleged campaign together.20

For you, an unwritten rule or belief that women do not belong in a job can explain the meaning of otherwise nonsexual obstruction or exclusion. The connection matters: ordinary disagreements about assignments do not become harassment merely because the participants have different genders.20, 1

Why a supervisor's gestures and exclusion can matter together

A supervisor's facial expressions and shunning can carry a discriminatory message in context. In Roby v. McKesson Corp. (2009) 47 Cal.4th 686, a disability case, a supervisor knew about an employee's medical condition yet reacted to its symptoms with degrading comments, disapproving expressions and exclusion. The California Supreme Court restored the harassment finding and explained that discriminatory personnel treatment and hostile social behavior can supply overlapping evidence.21

The distinction helps you describe a pattern accurately. An assignment or disciplinary action is usually a personnel decision rather than harassment by itself, but it can help show the bias behind a supervisor's slights and comments. The court's reasoning allows the evidence to be understood together while retaining the distinction between discrimination and harassment.21

When rumors attack how you earned your position

A sexual rumor can support a sex-based harassment claim when it uses a gender stereotype to undermine you. In Parker v. Reema Consulting Services, Inc. (4th Cir. 2019) 915 F.3d 297, an employee alleged that male coworkers, joined by the highest-ranking manager, spread a false rumor that the employee slept with a boss to get promoted, and that exclusion and different treatment followed. The federal appeals court allowed the employee's Title VII harassment claim to proceed because those allegations plausibly rested on a stereotype that women obtain advancement through sex.22

This federal case illustrates why the content, source and workplace use of a rumor matter; the California statutory question remains whether you experienced harassment because of a protected characteristic. For the separate rules governing comments, jokes and innuendo, see our verbal harassment guide.22, 1

When pregnancy or breastfeeding becomes the reason for humiliation

You can experience sex-based harassment aimed at pregnancy, childbirth or breastfeeding without any sexual advance. Government Code section 12940(j)(4)(C) expressly covers pregnancy, childbirth and related medical conditions, while Government Code section 12926(r) includes breastfeeding and its related conditions in the definition of sex. The relevant connection is why you are targeted, rather than whether anyone expresses attraction.1, 9

The Civil Rights Department's sample prevention policy also identifies pregnancy, childbirth and breastfeeding within its sexual-harassment provisions. If your employer uses a policy like this model, ridicule, visual mockery or exclusion aimed at those characteristics can violate it even before the conduct amounts to unlawful harassment, so describe it that way rather than as an ordinary personality conflict.27, 1, 9

Where the same-gender rule comes from

The protection against harassment by someone of your own gender, mentioned above, has both a federal and a California source. In Oncale v. Sundowner Offshore Services, Inc. (1998) 523 U.S. 75, an oil-rig worker alleged sexual humiliation, assault and threats by other men. A federal appeals court had held that a man could not bring a claim for harassment by male coworkers. The United States Supreme Court reversed, holding that federal workplace law can reach same-sex harassment when it occurs because of sex.23

In California, section 12940(j)(1) separately names sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression and sexual orientation as protected bases, and section 12940(j)(4)(C) removes any need to prove sexual desire. The Civil Rights Department likewise explains that same-gender harassment can occur regardless of either person's orientation or identity. You can therefore focus on the conduct and its meaning without having to establish a private attraction.1, 10

When someone tries to enforce a gender stereotype

The stereotype protection has a written definition. California Code of Regulations, title 2, section 11030 defines sex stereotypes to include assumptions about appearance, behavior, gender roles and ability to perform particular jobs. Government Code section 12926(r) and that regulation also cover gender identity and expression, including perceived identity or expression; protection does not depend on meeting another person's expectations.24, 9

This can explain nonsexual hostility toward your manner, presentation or role. Applying the definitions, ridicule aimed at a man's supposedly insufficient masculinity or a woman's supposed unsuitability for technical work can carry a sex-based message even without a proposition.24, 1

When your requested name or pronouns are deliberately disregarded

Deliberately refusing your requested name or pronouns can support a California claim. California Code of Regulations, title 2, section 11034(h)(3) says an employer or other covered entity that fails to honor a request for a preferred gender, name or pronoun may be liable under FEHA. The Civil Rights Department specifically identifies intentional use of the wrong name or pronouns as an example of gender-identity or gender-expression harassment.25, 26

You do not need surgery, a changed birth certificate or a legal name change to use a name and pronouns corresponding to your identity or expression. Section 11034(h)(4) permits use of the gender or legal name on a government-issued identity document only as necessary for a legally mandated obligation; that limited records exception does not authorize disregarding your chosen name throughout ordinary work.25, 26

When access to facilities becomes a test of your identity

You do not have to provide medical proof or identity documents to use facilities matching your gender identity or expression. Section 11034(e)(2) requires that access regardless of sex assigned at birth and prohibits medical treatment, procedures or documentation as prerequisites. Employers must provide feasible privacy measures for all workers, and cannot force you into a separate facility through policy or harassment.25, 26

The regulation allows a reasonable, confidential inquiry solely to ensure access to comparable, safe and adequate multi-user facilities. That narrow inquiry does not authorize a demand to prove surgery or to surrender the access the regulation protects. For you, separating a practical facilities discussion from an interrogation about your body makes the actual issue easier to identify.25

When questions about your body become conditions of employment

You do not ordinarily have to prove your gender or disclose transition details to keep your job. Section 11034(i)(1) prohibits employer inquiries or documentation demands concerning sex, gender, gender identity or gender expression as a condition of employment. It preserves the narrow bona fide occupational qualification defense and discussions that you initiate about working conditions.25

For intrusive questions during hiring, auditions or interviews, see our hiring-stage harassment guide.

Government Code section 12949 requires your employer to allow you to appear and dress consistently with your gender identity or gender expression, and section 11034(g) makes a conflicting appearance or dress standard unlawful unless the employer establishes business necessity. Our restaurant workers guide has a section on uniforms and appearance rules.32, 25

If your concern is what happened after you raised an objection, see our workplace retaliation guide.

Proving Non-Verbal and Visual Harassment Claims

One challenge with non-verbal and visual harassment is documentation. Unlike a written message, a leer or a gesture does not leave a timestamp. Here is how to build a strong case:

  1. Keep a contemporaneous log. After every incident, write it down immediately, the date, time, location, exactly what happened, who was present, and how you felt. This log is powerful evidence.
  2. Identify witnesses. If colleagues observed the conduct, note their names. They may be willing to provide statements or corroborate your account.
  3. Preserve visual evidence. If explicit images were sent to you, keep the message and photograph the screen with your own phone. If they were displayed, write down what you saw, when, where, and who was there. Ask a lawyer before forwarding company files to a personal account.
  4. Report to HR in writing. A written complaint creates a legal record and triggers the employer's obligation to investigate. Describe the specific conduct as precisely as possible.
  5. Check for surveillance footage. If the incident occurred in a recorded area, request that footage be preserved before it is overwritten. An attorney can help compel this through legal process if necessary.
Remember: You do not need perfect evidence before consulting an attorney. An experienced California employment lawyer can help you identify and preserve evidence you may not know exists, and advise you on the strength of your claim based on what you do have.

What can prove an incident that left no spoken words

Your own direct testimony can prove a fact even when nobody made a recording. Evidence Code section 411 makes the direct evidence of one fully credible witness sufficient unless another statute requires additional evidence; the fact finder still decides credibility and whether the whole claim is established. In the staring case discussed above, the worker's declaration and deposition described where the forklift driver was positioned, how often the driver appeared, how long the watching lasted, and what happened before and after complaints. Those specifics connected observable conduct to its alleged meaning; the opinion did not depend on camera footage.28, 3

Other workers' accounts can also help explain why conduct was directed at you. In Pantoja v. Anton (2011) 198 Cal.App.4th 87, the Court of Appeal reversed a judgment for the employer because other women's evidence of harassment should have been heard. That evidence could show gender bias and test the defense evidence that harassment was not tolerated and that profanity was not aimed at individuals. The evidence could serve those purposes even when the worker did not witness it, subject to the court's assessment of its value and potential unfair prejudice; it could not be admitted simply to prove bad character. Likewise, in Taylor v. Nabors Drilling USA, LP, the oil-rig case discussed above, the photograph and repeated conduct were evaluated together, rather than assuming a display proved every element on its own.29, 16

Read more: Sexual harassment evidence in California: texts, emails and recordings.

What Remedies Are Available

Victims of all forms of workplace sexual harassment, including non-verbal, visual, and digital, can pursue the same full range of remedies under California FEHA:

  • Lost wages and reinstatement if you left or were terminated
  • Compensatory damages for emotional distress and psychological harm
  • Medical and therapy expense reimbursement
  • Punitive damages for egregious employer conduct
  • Attorney's fees and costs if you prevail

The process begins with filing a complaint with the California Civil Rights Department (CRD), either to initiate their investigation or to obtain an immediate right-to-sue notice. You have three years from the last incident of harassment to file your CRD complaint, under Government Code section 12960(e)(5).

For the recovery available on a workplace claim, see our harassment case value guide.

For filing rules under Government Code section 12960(e)(5), see our California harassment deadlines guide.30

Related reading: harassment on Zoom, Slack and email, California hostile work environment laws, verbal, physical and visual harassment, inappropriate comments and innuendo, the types of sexual harassment, workplace harassment in California, what to do after a sexual assault at work, what to expect at a deposition, and quid pro quo harassment.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is non-verbal conduct like staring or sexual gestures considered harassment in California?

It can be. The Civil Rights Department lists leering, gestures, and blocking movement among the behaviors that may be sexual harassment. Persistent leering, sexual gestures, blocking movement, or suggestive body language that is unwelcome, happens because of sex, and is severe or pervasive is unlawful harassment under California law.

Can I file a harassment claim if someone showed me explicit images at work?

It can be. Exposing employees to sexually explicit images, videos, or materials, whether on screen, printed, or sent digitally, can be visual sexual harassment under FEHA when it is unwelcome, tied to sex, and severe or pervasive. It applies to shared screens, screensavers, printed materials, and content forwarded through work or personal channels.

What if I am not the direct target, can bystanders file harassment claims?

Sometimes. If harassment aimed at others happened in your immediate work environment and you personally witnessed it, you may have a hostile work environment claim, but courts require a higher showing than when you are the target. You do not need to be the primary target to have a claim.

Does cyberstalking or monitoring my social media by a coworker count as workplace harassment?

It can. Digital surveillance combined with sexualized commentary, unsolicited contact, or a broader pattern of harassing conduct can contribute to a hostile work environment claim. When combined with other conduct, it strengthens the overall pattern.

What if my employer says the harassing conduct happened "outside of work"?

That is not automatically a defense. Harassment that affects the work environment, messages that impact your work experience, conduct at work events, or conduct that makes work intolerable, can be actionable regardless of where it technically occurred. The test is whether it affected the conditions of your employment.

How long do I have to file a harassment claim in California?

Generally three years from the last act of harassment to file a complaint with the California Civil Rights Department (CRD), under Government Code section 12960(e)(5). After the CRD issues a right-to-sue notice, you generally have one year from the date of that notice to file a lawsuit. Consult an attorney promptly to preserve your rights.

Do I have to prove the person was attracted to me?

No, California's statute expressly says sexual desire is unnecessary. You still need to connect the conduct to sex or another protected characteristic, but gender harassment, such as hostility toward you because of your sex, can supply that connection without romantic interest.

Does accepting one gift mean I accepted continued romantic attention?

No, accepting a gift does not automatically establish that the whole pattern was welcome. The surrounding work relationship, your explanation and the course of conduct must be considered.

Does a disclaimer saying I did not take part in an altered sexual image defeat my claim?

No, a disclaimer in the material saying that you did not participate in or authorize its creation is not a defense under Civil Code section 1708.86. The material and disclosure still must satisfy the statute, including its consent, knowledge and exception rules.

Must I be pictured to sue over an unsolicited obscene image?

No, Civil Code section 1708.88 gives the qualifying recipient a civil claim. Its adult-sender, knowledge, obscenity, harm and exception requirements apply, including the exclusion where the recipient did not use an available express opt-out.

Can a posted notice authorize my employer to record the changing room?

No, a notice is not the court order required by Labor Code section 435. The provision bars an employer from causing audio or video recording of an employee in the specified rooms and from using an unlawful recording.

Must someone actually see the exposed genitals for indecent exposure?

No. The Judicial Council's jury instruction for indecent exposure, CALCRIM No. 1160, says it is not required that another person actually see the exposed genitals. The prosecution must still prove willful exposure in the presence of someone who might be offended or annoyed, and lewd intent.

Do I need a legal name change before using my chosen name at work?

No, the protection does not depend on a legal name change or medical transition. A particular legally required record may use your legal name, but that exception does not extend to every workplace interaction.

Can breastfeeding-related hostility count even when it is not sexual?

Yes, breastfeeding and related medical conditions are included in California's definition of sex. Harassment aimed at that characteristic does not require a sexual proposition; the workplace-harassment requirements still apply.

Not Sure If What Happened to You "Counts"? Let Us Help You Find Out.

Sexual harassment is not always easy to categorize, but the Eghbali Law Firm has seen it all. If something at your workplace has made you feel sexually targeted, unsafe, or unable to do your job with dignity, tell us what happened. We offer free, confidential consultations and handle all harassment cases on contingency.

Get a Free Confidential Consultation

Call (310) 909-8533 or fill out our confidential contact form. No judgment, no pressure.

Sources

  1. California Government Code section 12940, unlawful employment practices, including harassment.
  2. California Code of Regulations, title 2, section 11019, terms, conditions and privileges of employment, including the forms of harassment.
  3. Birschtein v. New United Motor Manufacturing, Inc. (2001) 92 Cal.App.4th 994, California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District.
  4. Christian v. Umpqua Bank (9th Cir. 2020) 984 F.3d 801, United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.
  5. California Civil Code section 1708.86, civil action for digitized sexually explicit material.
  6. California Civil Code section 1708.88, civil action for unsolicited obscene images sent by electronic means.
  7. California Penal Code section 647, disorderly conduct, including viewing, recording and image distribution in subdivision (j).
  8. California Labor Code section 435, employer audio or video recording in restrooms, locker rooms and changing rooms.
  9. California Government Code section 12926, definitions, including sex in subdivision (r).
  10. California Civil Rights Department, Sexual Harassment Fact Sheet, CRD-185-ENG, September 2022 edition.
  11. California Penal Code section 314, willful and lewd exposure.
  12. Judicial Council of California, Criminal Jury Instructions (CALCRIM), 2026 edition, No. 1160, Indecent Exposure, printed pages 935 to 938.
  13. California Government Code section 12923, legislative declarations on the hostile work environment standard.
  14. Wawrzenski v. United Airlines, Inc. (2024) 106 Cal.App.5th 663, California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District.
  15. Lewis v. City of Benicia (2014) 224 Cal.App.4th 1519, California Court of Appeal, First Appellate District.
  16. Taylor v. Nabors Drilling USA, LP (2014) 222 Cal.App.4th 1228, California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District.
  17. Herberg v. California Institute of the Arts (2002) 101 Cal.App.4th 142, California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District.
  18. Lyle v. Warner Brothers Television Productions (2006) 38 Cal.4th 264, California Supreme Court.
  19. Judicial Council of California, 2024 Summary of Court-Related Legislation, December 2024.
  20. Accardi v. Superior Court (1993) 17 Cal.App.4th 341, California Court of Appeal, Second Appellate District.
  21. Roby v. McKesson Corp. (2009) 47 Cal.4th 686, California Supreme Court.
  22. Parker v. Reema Consulting Services, Inc. (4th Cir. 2019) 915 F.3d 297, United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit.
  23. Oncale v. Sundowner Offshore Services, Inc. (1998) 523 U.S. 75, United States Supreme Court.
  24. California Code of Regulations, title 2, section 11030, definitions, including sex stereotype.
  25. California Code of Regulations, title 2, section 11034, terms, conditions, and privileges of employment, including gender identity and gender expression.
  26. California Civil Rights Department, The Rights of Employees Who Are Transgender or Gender Nonconforming, poster CRD-E04P-ENG, December 2023 edition.
  27. California Civil Rights Department, Discrimination, Harassment, and Retaliation Prevention: Sample EEO Policy, March 2025 edition, a model policy for employers.
  28. California Evidence Code section 411, direct evidence of one witness.
  29. Pantoja v. Anton (2011) 198 Cal.App.4th 87, California Court of Appeal, Fifth Appellate District.
  30. California Government Code section 12960, complaints to the Civil Rights Department, including the filing period in subdivision (e)(5).
  31. Judicial Council of California, 2025 Summary of Court-Related Legislation, December 2025.
  32. California Government Code section 12949, appearance and dress consistent with gender identity or gender expression.

Legal Disclaimer: This page is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Employment law is complex and fact-specific. The information on this page reflects California law as of 2026 and may change. If you believe your rights have been violated, please consult a licensed California employment attorney to evaluate your specific situation.

Talk to a California employment lawyer today.

Free, confidential consultation. We represent employees only, never employers.